Makes linker functions have small error sets, required to report
diagnostics properly rather than having a massive error set that has a
lot of codes.
Other linker implementations are not ported yet.
Also the branch is not passing semantic analysis yet.
The goals of this branch are to:
* compile faster when using the wasm linker and backend
* enable saving compiler state by directly copying in-memory linker
state to disk.
* more efficient compiler memory utilization
* introduce integer type safety to wasm linker code
* generate better WebAssembly code
* fully participate in incremental compilation
* do as much work as possible outside of flush(), while continuing to do
linker garbage collection.
* avoid unnecessary heap allocations
* avoid unnecessary indirect function calls
In order to accomplish this goals, this removes the ZigObject
abstraction, as well as Symbol and Atom. These abstractions resulted
in overly generic code, doing unnecessary work, and needless
complications that simply go away by creating a better in-memory data
model and emitting more things lazily.
For example, this makes wasm codegen emit MIR which is then lowered to
wasm code during linking, with optimal function indexes etc, or
relocations are emitted if outputting an object. Previously, this would
always emit relocations, which are fully unnecessary when emitting an
executable, and required all function calls to use the maximum size LEB
encoding.
This branch introduces the concept of the "prelink" phase which occurs
after all object files have been parsed, but before any Zcu updates are
sent to the linker. This allows the linker to fully parse all objects
into a compact memory model, which is guaranteed to be complete when Zcu
code is generated.
This commit is not a complete implementation of all these goals; it is
not even passing semantic analysis.
This commit separates semantic analysis of the annotated type vs value
of a global declaration, therefore allowing recursive and mutually
recursive values to be declared.
Every `Nav` which undergoes analysis now has *two* corresponding
`AnalUnit`s: `.{ .nav_val = n }` and `.{ .nav_ty = n }`. The `nav_val`
unit is responsible for *fully resolving* the `Nav`: determining its
value, linksection, addrspace, etc. The `nav_ty` unit, on the other
hand, resolves only the information necessary to construct a *pointer*
to the `Nav`: its type, addrspace, etc. (It does also analyze its
linksection, but that could be moved to `nav_val` I think; it doesn't
make any difference).
Analyzing a `nav_ty` for a declaration with no type annotation will just
mark a dependency on the `nav_val`, analyze it, and finish. Conversely,
analyzing a `nav_val` for a declaration *with* a type annotation will
first mark a dependency on the `nav_ty` and analyze it, using this as
the result type when evaluating the value body.
The `nav_val` and `nav_ty` units always have references to one another:
so, if a `Nav`'s type is referenced, its value implicitly is too, and
vice versa. However, these dependencies are trivial, so, to save memory,
are only known implicitly by logic in `resolveReferences`.
In general, analyzing ZIR `decl_val` will only analyze `nav_ty` of the
corresponding `Nav`. There are two exceptions to this. If the
declaration is an `extern` declaration, then we immediately ensure the
`Nav` value is resolved (which doesn't actually require any more
analysis, since such a declaration has no value body anyway).
Additionally, if the resolved type has type tag `.@"fn"`, we again
immediately resolve the `Nav` value. The latter restriction is in place
for two reasons:
* Functions are special, in that their externs are allowed to trivially
alias; i.e. with a declaration `extern fn foo(...)`, you can write
`const bar = foo;`. This is not allowed for non-function externs, and
it means that function types are the only place where it is possible
for a declaration `Nav` to have a `.@"extern"` value without actually
being declared `extern`. We need to identify this situation
immediately so that the `decl_ref` can create a pointer to the *real*
extern `Nav`, not this alias.
* In certain situations, such as taking a pointer to a `Nav`, Sema needs
to queue analysis of a runtime function if the value is a function. To
do this, the function value needs to be known, so we need to resolve
the value immediately upon `&foo` where `foo` is a function.
This restriction is simple to codify into the eventual language
specification, and doesn't limit the utility of this feature in
practice.
A consequence of this commit is that codegen and linking logic needs to
be more careful when looking at `Nav`s. In general:
* When `updateNav` or `updateFunc` is called, it is safe to assume that
the `Nav` being updated (the owner `Nav` for `updateFunc`) is fully
resolved.
* Any `Nav` whose value is/will be an `@"extern"` or a function is fully
resolved; see `Nav.getExtern` for a helper for a common case here.
* Any other `Nav` may only have its type resolved.
This didn't seem to be too tricky to satisfy in any of the existing
codegen/linker backends.
Resolves: #131
Previous commits
2b0929929d4ea2f441df
had this text:
> There are no dir components, so you would think that this was
> unreachable, however we have observed on macOS two processes racing to
> do openat() with O_CREAT manifest in ENOENT.
This appears to have been a misunderstanding based on the issue
report #12138 and corresponding PR #12139 in which the steps to
reproduce removed the cache directory in a loop which also executed
detached Zig compiler processes.
There is no evidence for the macOS kernel bug however the ENOENT is
easily explained by the removal of the cache directory.
This commit reverts those commits, ultimately reporting the ENOENT as an
error rather than repeating the create file operation. However this
commit also adds an explicit error set to `std.Build.Cache.hit` as well
as changing the `failed_file_index` to a proper diagnostic field that
fully communicates what failed, leading to more informative error
messages on failure to check the cache.
The equivalent failure when occuring for AstGen performs a fatal process
kill, reasoning being that the compiler has an invariant of the cache
directory not being yanked out from underneath it while executing. This
could be made a more granular error in the future but I suspect such
thing is not valuable to pursue.
Related to #18340 but does not solve it.
Primarily, this moves linker input parsing from flush() into the linker
task queue, which is executed simultaneously with the frontend.
I also made it avoid redundantly opening the same archive file N times
for each object file inside. Furthermore, hard code fixed buffer stream
rather than using a generic stream type.
Finally, I fixed the error handling of the Wasm.Archive.parse function.
Please pay attention to this pattern of returning a struct rather than
accepting a mutable struct as an argument. This ensures function-level
atomicity and makes resource management straightforward.
Deletes the file and path fields from Archive and Object.
Removed a well-meaning but ultimately misguided suggestion about how to
think about ZigObject since thinking about it that way has led to
problematic anti-DOD patterns.
* AIX has its own bespoke format.
* Handle all Apple platforms.
* FreeBSD and OpenBSD both use the GNU format in LLVM.
* Windows has since been switched to the COFF format by default in LLVM.
LLVM recently introduced new Triple::ArchType members in 19.1.3 which broke our
static assertions in zig_llvm.cpp. When implementing a fix for that, I realized
that we don't even need a lot of the stuff we have in zig_llvm.(cpp,h) anymore.
This commit trims the interface down considerably.
these tasks have some shared data dependencies so they cannot be done
simultaneously. Future work should untangle these data dependencies so
that more can be done in parallel.
for now this commit ensures correctness by making linker input parsing
and codegen tasks part of the same queue.
* Compilation.objects changes to Compilation.link_inputs which stores
objects, archives, windows resources, shared objects, and strings
intended to be put directly into the dynamic section. Order is now
preserved between all of these kinds of linker inputs. If it is
determined the order does not matter for a particular kind of linker
input, that item should be moved to a different array.
* rename system_libs to windows_libs
* untangle library lookup from CLI types
* when doing library lookup, instead of using access syscalls, go ahead
and open the files and keep the handles around for passing to the
cache system and the linker.
* during library lookup and cache file hashing, use positioned reads to
avoid affecting the file seek position.
* library directories are opened in the CLI and converted to Directory
objects, warnings emitted for those that cannot be opened.
along with the relevant logic, making the libraries within subject to
the same search criteria as all the other libraries.
this unfortunately means doing file system access on all .so files when
targeting ELF to determine if they are linker scripts, however, I have a
plan to address this.
Make shared_objects a StringArrayHashMap so that deduping does not
need to happen in flush. That deduping code also was using an O(N^2)
algorithm, which is not allowed in this codebase. There is another
violation of this rule in resolveSymbols but this commit does not
address it.
This required reworking shared object parsing, breaking it into
independent components so that we could access soname earlier.
Shared object parsing had a few problems that I noticed and fixed in
this commit:
* Many instances of incorrect use of align(1).
* `shnum * @sizeOf(elf.Elf64_Shdr)` can overflow based on user data.
* `@divExact` can cause illegal behavior based on user data.
* Strange versyms logic that wasn't present in mold nor lld. The logic
was not commented and there is no git blame information in ziglang/zig
nor kubkon/zld. I changed it to match mold and lld instead.
* Use of ArrayList for slices of memory that are never resized.
* finding DT_VERDEFNUM in a different loop than finding DT_SONAME.
Ultimately I think we should follow mold's lead and ignore this
integer, relying on null termination instead.
* Doing logic based on VER_FLG_BASE rather than ignoring it like mold
and LLD do. No comment explaining why the behavior is different.
* Mutating the original ELF symbols rather than only storing the mangled
name on the new Symbol struct.
I noticed something that I didn't try to address in this commit: Symbol
stores a lot of redundant information that is already present in the ELF
symbols. I suspect that the codebase could benefit from reworking Symbol
to not store redundant information.
Additionally:
* Add some type safety to std.elf.
* Eliminate 1-3 file system reads for determining the kind of input
files, by taking advantage of file name extension and handling error
codes properly.
* Move more error handling methods to link.Diags and make them
infallible and thread-safe
* Make the data dependencies obvious in the parameters of
parseSharedObject. It's now clear that the first two steps (Header and
Parsed) can be done during the main Compilation pipeline, rather than
waiting for flush().
By organizing linker diagnostics into this struct, it becomes possible
to share more code between linker backends, and more importantly it
becomes possible to pass only the Diag struct to some functions, rather
than passing the entire linker state object in. This makes data
dependencies more obvious, making it easier to rearrange code and to
multithread.
Also fix MachO code abusing an atomic variable. Not only was it using
the wrong atomic operation, it is unnecessary additional state since
the state is already being protected by a mutex.
Embrace the Path abstraction, doing more operations based on directory
handles rather than absolute file paths. Most of the diff noise here
comes from this one.
Fix sorting of crtbegin/crtend atoms. Previously it would look at all
path components for those strings.
Make the C runtime path detection partially a pure function, and move
some logic to glibc.zig where it belongs.
flush() must not do anything more than necessary. Determining the type
of input files must be done only once, before flush. Fortunately, we
don't even need any file system accesses to do this since that
information is statically known in most cases, and in the rest of the
cases can be determined by file extension alone.
This commit also updates the nearby code to conform to the convention
for error handling where there is exactly one error code to represent
the fact that error messages have already been emitted. This had the
side effect of improving the error message for a linker script parse
error.
"positionals" is not a linker concept; it is a command line interface
concept. Zig's linker implementation should not mention "positionals".
This commit deletes that array list in favor of directly making function
calls, eliminating that heap allocation during flush().
The goal is to minimize as much as possible how much logic is inside
flush(). So let's start by moving out obvious stuff. This data can be
preformatted before flush().
See: https://devblogs.microsoft.com/directx/directx-adopting-spir-v
Since we never hooked up the (experimental) DirectX LLVM backend, we've never
actually supported targeting DXIL in Zig. With Microsoft moving away from DXIL,
that seems very unlikely to change.
The compiler actually doesn't need any functional changes for this: Sema
does reification based on the tag indices of `std.builtin.Type` already!
So, no zig1.wasm update is necessary.
This change is necessary to disallow name clashes between fields and
decls on a type, which is a prerequisite of #9938.
This type is exactly the same as std.Build.Cache.Path, except for
one function which is not used anymore. Therefore we can replace
it without consequences.
A compilation build step for which the binary is not required could not
be compiled previously. There were 2 issues that caused this:
- The compiler communicated only the results of the emitted binary and
did not properly communicate the result if the binary was not emitted.
This is fixed by communicating the final hash of the artifact path (the
hash of the corresponding /o/<hash> directory) and communicating this
instead of the entire path. This changes the zig build --listen protocol
to communicate hashes instead of paths, and emit_bin_path is accordingly
renamed to emit_digest.
- There was an error related to the default llvm object path when
CacheUse.Whole was selected. I'm not really sure why this didn't manifest
when the binary is also emitted.
This was fixed by improving the path handling related to flush() and
emitLlvmObject().
In general, this commit also improves some of the path handling throughout
the compiler and standard library.
The type `Zcu.Decl` in the compiler is problematic: over time it has
gained many responsibilities. Every source declaration, container type,
generic instantiation, and `@extern` has a `Decl`. The functions of
these `Decl`s are in some cases entirely disjoint.
After careful analysis, I determined that the two main responsibilities
of `Decl` are as follows:
* A `Decl` acts as the "subject" of semantic analysis at comptime. A
single unit of analysis is either a runtime function body, or a
`Decl`. It registers incremental dependencies, tracks analysis errors,
etc.
* A `Decl` acts as a "global variable": a pointer to it is consistent,
and it may be lowered to a specific symbol by the codegen backend.
This commit eliminates `Decl` and introduces new types to model these
responsibilities: `Cau` (Comptime Analysis Unit) and `Nav` (Named
Addressable Value).
Every source declaration, and every container type requiring resolution
(so *not* including `opaque`), has a `Cau`. For a source declaration,
this `Cau` performs the resolution of its value. (When #131 is
implemented, it is unsolved whether type and value resolution will share
a `Cau` or have two distinct `Cau`s.) For a type, this `Cau` is the
context in which type resolution occurs.
Every non-`comptime` source declaration, every generic instantiation,
and every distinct `extern` has a `Nav`. These are sent to codegen/link:
the backends by definition do not care about `Cau`s.
This commit has some minor technically-breaking changes surrounding
`usingnamespace`. I don't think they'll impact anyone, since the changes
are fixes around semantics which were previously inconsistent (the
behavior changed depending on hashmap iteration order!).
Aside from that, this changeset has no significant user-facing changes.
Instead, it is an internal refactor which makes it easier to correctly
model the responsibilities of different objects, particularly regarding
incremental compilation. The performance impact should be negligible,
but I will take measurements before merging this work into `master`.
Co-authored-by: Jacob Young <jacobly0@users.noreply.github.com>
Co-authored-by: Jakub Konka <kubkon@jakubkonka.com>
